When the wells run dry

Those critical of Western sanctions against Russia usually point at the fact that these measures have so far failed to do their job. They failed to bring meaningful changes in Russia’s foreign and domestic policies and failed to stop the war in the Donbas. Critics are partly right. Certainly, it took the West too long to force Vladimir Putin to the negotiating table. On the other hand, if the purpose of the West was to weaken Russia and to simultaneously split the political elite, thereby paving the way for changes in the longer term, they are on the right track. 

Continue reading

Posted in Policies, Society | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

The cost of peace

The war in Ukraine is, arguably, a very costly business for Russia’s leaders. No wonder that the political and business elite seem to be increasingly divided on the issue. However, the situation created by the conflict has benefited Russia’s ruling political class and personally Vladimir Putin in a different way: it granted the President an almost unprecedented hegemony over the Russian political sphere. Putin should, however, know that this hegemony is temporary. Therefore, while he is still able to accumulate further political capital, he will try to finish the redistribution of power and wealth that started together with his third term. This is expected to cost Dmitry Medvedev his position.

Continue reading

Posted in Elections, Kremlinology | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Putin’s Milosevic moment

As the world is gearing up for the upcoming talks between Vladimir Putin, Petro Poroshenko and Western officials in Minsk next week, all sides seem to pretend that time works for them and stakes are higher on the other side. The Ukrainian army, while suffering heavy losses, claims that it is close to the total annihilation of rebels. The EU, marred by internal debates on Russia’s present and possible future counter-sanctions, including a gas war, is trying to show unity and determination. Russia, despite an obvious panic among some of its largest businesses – such as Rosneft or VTB – acts as if it were winning the conflict in Ukraine. While such a chicken-game, many fear, might as well turn the conflict into a full-scale war, there is something that has to make Putin extremely cautious: he cannot know when he is about to reach his ‘Milosevic moment’.

Continue reading

Posted in Policies, Society | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Why sanctions may as well work

Two days ago, Clifford Gaddy and Barry Ickes, two renowned experts on Russia’s economy published a short analysis on the possible effect of European and American sanctions on Russia. The outlook was grim, they concluded: not only were sanctions unlikely to produce the desired effect, but they would also lead to an increased state control over the Russian economy and they would make the Russian public rally around Vladimir Putin. While the two gentlemen make a number of valid and important points, I still think that sanctions, if properly implemented and accompanied by an adequate show of political will, do work. Here’s why.

Continue reading

Posted in Policies, Society | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Not a golden opportunity

One of the conclusions many have drawn from the tragedy of flight MH17 was that Vladimir Putin now had the golden opportunity to withdraw from Ukraine – a war he had wanted to end anyway – and blame it all on the separatists. However, somehow this does not seem to be happening. The war has continued and Russia put the blame on Ukraine. This is not a surprise: there has never been a golden opportunity. Putin did want to exit the war but he wanted to do it on his own terms. This choice is what he lost in the disaster on Thursday. 

Continue reading

Posted in Policies, Society | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

A tragedy with consequences

This is the end of the conflict in Ukraine as we know it. 

Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Go back to Start, do not collect $200bn

Sometimes words can hurt more than actions. Last week, the president of the European Central Bank, Mario Draghi said that capital flight from Russia might be four times as high as reported by Russia’s government. So far, the finance ministry reported $ 51 billion in the first qurter, while, according to Draghi, ECB estimates total outflows to have reached $ 222 billion this year. At the same time, there is significant suspicion that not only the official numbers on capital flight but also the ones on Russia’s currency reserves ($ 477 billion) are bogus, following the Russian Central Bank’s efforts in the past weeks to protect the rouble. Regardless of whether these assumptions are right, the mere fact that it is just plausible to assume that Russia is lying about its important economic indicators may soon lead to serious consequences. By all accounts, Russia may be headed towards a 1998-type crisis.

Continue reading

Posted in Policies, Society | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment